- 06 Apr 2018 01:09
#14903531
Agreed. did not deny.
Agreed. Did not deny.
I didn't, I went off of their own definitions.
Agreed,
It is definitive for an AnCap world though....
An AnCap may not personally own land, but that is irrelevant to the fact that an AnCap worldview posits private property absolutism as fundamental. The latter is consistent with AnCap, the former is not. The former is Georgism, the latter is not.
Georgism believes that all private property should be abolished in exchange for collective ownership, not that private property can merely be converted to localized collective ownership by consent of its proprietor, which are entirely different matters.
"It is when a people forget God that tyrants forge their chains. A vitiated state of morals... is incompatible with freedom."
- Patrick Henry
Libertarian353 wrote:A landowner can do what he wants as he pleases.
Agreed. did not deny.
Libertarian353 wrote:If he decides that anarcho-communism is the way to go he can choose to relinquish his land to the tenets and join them. It's all about NAP and consent.
Agreed. Did not deny.
Libertarian353 wrote:Who are you to decide what's communist/georgist/nationalist/theocrat/leftist/etc?
I didn't, I went off of their own definitions.
Libertarian353 wrote:The idea is freedom of choice and non-coercion.
Agreed,
Libertarian353 wrote:Property is essential but not the end all be all.
It is definitive for an AnCap world though....
Libertarian353 wrote:Not every ancap will own land, it's about making money and freedom of what's best for yourself.
An AnCap may not personally own land, but that is irrelevant to the fact that an AnCap worldview posits private property absolutism as fundamental. The latter is consistent with AnCap, the former is not. The former is Georgism, the latter is not.
Georgism believes that all private property should be abolished in exchange for collective ownership, not that private property can merely be converted to localized collective ownership by consent of its proprietor, which are entirely different matters.
"It is when a people forget God that tyrants forge their chains. A vitiated state of morals... is incompatible with freedom."
- Patrick Henry