New York Times Public Editor: "There Could Have Been, And Should Have Been, Much More" Reporting On Flint Water Crisis. New York Times Public Editor Margaret Sullivan said there "could have been, and should have been, much more" coverage in The Times of Flint's water crisis. She noted that the newspaper published a "frightening article" about the water in March 2015, but then "more than six months went by" before the paper published two more articles in October, and then The Times wrote "nothing of substance until [January 2016], when a state of emergency was declared in Flint." She said The Times "got off to a strong start with its initial Flint story" but that the paper missed an opportunity to follow up "with some serious digging," which might have "shamed" public officials "into taking action long before they did." She continued:
Imagine if The Times really had taken on the Flint outrage with energy and persistence many months ago. With its powerful pulpit and reach, The Times could have held public officials accountable and prevented human suffering. That's what journalistic watchdogs are supposed to do. As traditional local investigative reporting withers, The Times's role becomes ever more important.
Yes, that takes journalistic resources. Investigative reporting is notoriously time-consuming. But are such resources really unavailable?
After all, enough Times firepower somehow has been found to document Hillary Clinton's every sneeze, Donald Trump's latest bombast, and Marco Rubio's shiny boots. There seem to be plenty of Times resources for such hit-seeking missives as "breadfacing" or the Magazine's thorough exploration of buffalo plaid and "lumbersexuals." And staff was available to produce this week's dare-you-not-to-click video on the rising social movement known as "Free the Nipple."
[...]
If The Times had kept the pressure on the Flint story, the resulting journalism might not have made the "trending" list -- but it would have made a real difference to the people of Flint, who were in serious need of a powerful ally. [The New York Times, 1/27/16]
National Journal's Ron Fournier Admitted He "Blew It." In a January 20 National Journal column headlined "How Government--and This Columnist--Failed Flint," Fournier acknowledged that he "blew it" by failing to bring up Flint's water crisis in a December 2015 column about Michigan Governor Rick Snyder's "refreshing approach to politics." [National Journal, 1/20/16]
CNN's Jake Tapper Apologized For Taking "So Long To Get On This Story." During an interview with Flint Mayor Karen Weaver on the January 20 edition of CNN's The Lead with Jake Tapper, Tapper apologized for failing to cover the Flint crisis over the many months that it was becoming worse and worse. After promising to "shame" Snyder or President Obama if they don't provide Weaver with "the response you need," Tapper admitted, "I'm sorry that it took us so long to get on this story." [CNN, The Lead with Jake Tapper, 1/20/16 via Media Matters]
Fox News' Media Critic: Flint Crisis "Hardly The Media's Finest Hour." On the January 31 edition of Fox News' Media Buzz, host Howard Kurtz said the Flint water crisis "is a national disgrace and hardly the media' finest hour." Kurtz said that "local journalist Curt Guyette did the most to cover this outrage, but he was working for the ACLU, not a news organization." He added that the New York Times "deserves credit" for its initial story on Flint's water and MSNBC also "touched on the problem," before pointing to Margaret Sullivan's critique of the Times' overall coverage. Kurtz concluded: "Good for Margaret Sullivan for challenging her paper and really, all of us, to do better."
Poynter Institute Noted Criticism Of National Media Coverage, Praise For Local Coverage. In a column headlined "How the media blew Flint," James Warren, chief media writer for the Poynter Institute, said that national media coverage of Flint's water crisis "seem[s] a little belated." He quoted David Poulson of Michigan State University's Knight Center for Environmental Journalism, who said that "perhaps aggressive coverage of local government under the state-appointed financial manager would have caught the issue earlier, or even prevented it from happening." He also cited Tom Henry, a reporter for Toledo's The Blade, who argued that "a lot" of the media failure "comes down to the decay of American journalism as well as decay of local government as costs for roads, sewers, police and everything else crippled budgets." However, Warren reported that Poulson gave "good marks" to local reporters "including Ron Fonger at The Flint Journal and Michigan Public Radio," and Henry gave "kudos" to "Chad Livengood and Jim Lynch of the Detroit News and also to the Detroit Free Press."
Syndicated Columnist Leonard Pitts: News Media "Failed" Its "Mission" And "Left The Poor Under Cover Of Darkness." Syndicated columnist Leonard Pitts wrote on January 19:
It was in April of 2014 that the water turned bad. Residents of Flint reported that the stuff smelled. It was yellowish brown. You drank it and your hair fell out. Or you developed a rash. Or you were nauseous.
Again, this was in April.
According to a computer search, it was not until the following January that the Detroit Free Press, just an hour down the road, took note. It wasn't until March that The New York Times began reporting the story. It wasn't until Jan. 5th of this year -- almost two years later -- that Michigan Gov. Rick Snyder saw fit to declare a state of emergency and nine days afterward that he asked President Obama to declare the city a disaster area.
And it is not until today that yours truly is writing about it.
[...]
[N]ews media have left the poor under cover of darkness. Our light shines on politics, the middle class, technological gimmickry and celebrity gossip, yes. But on those the Bible calls "the least of these"? Not so much. Our inattention frees politicians to ignore them as well. And all of a sudden you look up and it's been almost two years since 100,000 people had safe water to drink and we're just beginning to notice.
That's unconscionable. News media's mission, it is often said, is to afflict the comfortable and comfort the afflicted. Where the plight of the nation's poor is concerned, we seem to have failed on both counts. [Miami Herald, 1/19/16]
https://www.mediamatters.org/research/2 ... diacovered