Kaiserschmarrn wrote:Honestly, it is beyond me why people think a ceremonial head of state who is elected is better and actually feel strongly about it. Especially in a European context how can you not come to the conclusion that constitutional monarchies are at least as good as or better than republics?
The same way the lords needs banishing. You are giving power to unelected tax dodgers who happen to be born into nobility. If you are elected, you have at least earned your status.
As for monarch success in Europe, that is debatable. Wilhelm II and Nicholas II were European failures. The only thing keeping the Windsor going the same way is economics. During hard times, as proven throughout history, the poverty poor will go against the ruling elite if they can't put food on the table. And the fact the Royals are nothing more than figureheads for glossy magazines to idolise over, means they are just as useless as the Kardashians btw. I can't see any way of distinguishing differences between them. But at least Kayne keeps things interesting. And that is a plus on their part.
Additionally, it's pretty clear that a substantial part of the population loves their respective royals. I'd rather have them follow and be fascinated with them than the Kardashians or similar. Royals make far superior role models than pretty much any celebrity or pop star I can think of.
Yes, but a substantial part of the population love football too. Perhaps we should have King Beckham or King Southgate. At least they provide entertainment for ninty minutes rather than going around the Commonwealth offending the natives.
Then you have the history, continuity and tradition of the royal houses.
Big woop. Just proves they are all imbreds. At least Harry has Hewitt blood and so isn't plagued by unlikeability like Charles.
I think it was certainly a mistake to get rid of the Austrian royals or at least nothing was gained from it.
But nothing is lost from it either. If the Royals died off tomorrow, people would still come to visit royal building because people like history. Do you think people don't visit Bastille anymore or something?