Wandering the information superhighway, he came upon the last refuge of civilization, PoFo, the only forum on the internet ...
Moderator: PoFo Today's News Mods
demima wrote:Hilarious that people think something as insignificant as this will eventually lead to a degenerate society or the end of Western civilisation. Talk about navel gazing to the extreme.
Drlee wrote:I have not heard this but I am not surprised by it. Without any evidence here are some thoughts.
It could be that people suffering gender dysphoria seek out the military in an attempt to suppress their feelings. Where better to "butch up" than in the military. So this having failed, the person seeks the gender reassignment they were fearing for so long.
It could also be that the military life and its overtly male culture contrasted with the current US zeitgeist leads to seeking to abandon male gender in protest against that culture. What is the most "anti-military" action? How about abandoning manhood in favor of womanhood? And one could see female to male reassignment in the same light; joining behavior rather than protesting. My suspicion is that the overwhelming majority of these GID cases are male to female.
Then there is the possibility that the male soldier, traumatized by the stresses of combat (or even just military life) escapes in the most irrevocable way ever.
I have another thought about male to female adult gender reassignment. Could it be that the person transitioning rejects homosexuality and finds transgenderism a way to have sex with men without being "gay".
Drlee wrote:I am deeply skeptical of childhood gender reassingment. Even of the diagnosis at at all. I am also skeptical of adult transgenderism. Or at least the relative ease with which we allow this odd behavior.
From an epidemiological standpoint, the highly technical explanation for my concerns goes something like this: There is something rotten in Denmark and it ain't the fish".
I'm wary of psycho-dynamic explanations as a basis for illnesses (assuming you agree that GID is an illness), because they lack sound evidence as to the mechanism of conscious or subconscious thought causing chronic or long term debilitating symptoms and they have been proven wrong again and again. Historically, illnesses have only ever moved out of the category of psychosomatic/psychogenic illness, as we've become more advanced in measuring organic/physical changes in the body.
I think we had a conversation about this before, so you probably know that I share your skepticism. However, I'm quite confident that GD/transgenderism exists and that it can cause profound suffering.
I like the best case scenario - any school shooter[…]
This is just another "Trump is special"[…]
The subject's cynical realism dissolves precisely […]
What the neo conservative hawks President GW Bush,[…]