Pants-of-dog wrote:Hmm. You seem to have forgotten that you are discussing three things.
No, as the veto was for an amendment to the nationalisation law that would regulate said law. The nationalisation would still be legal. It would just be regulated.
Whether or not the refusal to carry out court orders was illegal or unconstitutional, this has nothing to do with the veto.
And finally, the motion was also not related to the veto or the refusal to carry out judicial orders, except insofar as all three were attacks against his presidency and his attempts to democratically institute socialism, and that each previous attack became a justification for the next one.
To be honest, Dorta is a little unclear here, but hey, English is not his first language and he is not a scholar.
Actually, he was attempting to give control of the means of the production to the working class while simultaneously following a legal system designed by the bourgeoisie and the aristocrats. This is, unfortunately, the burden of democratic socialism: to use the system against itself.
The vast majority of what he did was legal and constitutional.
His use of Decrees of Insistence were no different from any POTUS’s use of executive orders.
In fact, the only thing that he did that is arguably illegal was to selectively enforce court penalties. The correct response, in that situation, is to impeach the head of state and preserve government continuity, not get a foreign government to conspire with the military to install an authoritarian regime.
Apparently, you believe that “what all good citizens should do with a tyrant“ is sell out to a foreign government and get an even worse tyrant.
I am beginning to realize that Sivad has some of the most faulty, illogical, and nasty sense of political analysis and probably hates anyone who is poor.
Got to discard him as a man with no sense of fairness. None. Next!!
He should be thrown into the gulag where he might learn to be humble and have to share poverty for once and find out all his class conscious arrogant and erroneous opinions are totally worthless.
Seriously, Sivad is never going to understand anything about much.