- 14 Jun 2016 15:04
#14689871
I mean specifically, how is "spirituality" defined in this subforum so as to expressly exclude "atheists" from discussion of it?
As an agnostic with a strong bias toward atheism, I'm inclined to be offended by this censorship, but I'll resist the impulse, at least until I hear the justification. I know many atheists who consider themselves spiritual people, and who have a lot to say about spiritual practice.
Perhaps you mean "theism", not "spirituality". In that case, why should atheists be excluded from participation in a subforum dedicated to a discussion of theism? Aren't there philosophical accounts of theism that are more or less consistent with some forms of atheism and agnosticism? Are political conservatives excluded from the liberalism subforum on this site, or vice versa? Is there an analogous subforum from which theists are excluded from participation, somewhere on this site? Isn't it part of the purpose of an online community like this, to promote communication on contentious issues among people with a wide range of divergent views?
I'd appreciate an account of this special exclusionary provision, from account administrators, theists, spiritual people, or anyone else who happens to pass by.
As an agnostic with a strong bias toward atheism, I'm inclined to be offended by this censorship, but I'll resist the impulse, at least until I hear the justification. I know many atheists who consider themselves spiritual people, and who have a lot to say about spiritual practice.
Perhaps you mean "theism", not "spirituality". In that case, why should atheists be excluded from participation in a subforum dedicated to a discussion of theism? Aren't there philosophical accounts of theism that are more or less consistent with some forms of atheism and agnosticism? Are political conservatives excluded from the liberalism subforum on this site, or vice versa? Is there an analogous subforum from which theists are excluded from participation, somewhere on this site? Isn't it part of the purpose of an online community like this, to promote communication on contentious issues among people with a wide range of divergent views?
I'd appreciate an account of this special exclusionary provision, from account administrators, theists, spiritual people, or anyone else who happens to pass by.