[Albert]

[Eauz]

Remind me again why we let women vote ans have an opinion in how society functions ?

[One Degree]

Remind me again why we let women vote ans have an opinion in how society functions ?

They withheld sex and meals until we agreed.

[Eauz]

Uhh, sex dolls and microwavable meals.

[Eauz]

With rights come responsibility and some of them are not being responsible. Should be revoked for certain people.

[Pants-of-dog]

I agree with @Eauz.

If you hate women, you should not have sex with them or eat meals with them.

[Ter]

To get back to the subject of this thread, would our resident feminists agree that the false accuser should get the same sentence the accused would have received now that she was caught lying ?

[Red_Army]

My favorite type of MRA is the one who just waits for women to commit crimes so they can announce to the world that women sometimes do bad things.

I have a new topic: when my wife and I have sex while both of us are drunk who do you guys think is the rapist?

[One Degree]

Individuals suspected of making a false accusation of rape may be charged with the civil crime of "wasting police time" or the criminal charge of "Perverting the Course of Justice". Over a five-year period ending in 2014, a total of 109 women were prosecuted for crimes related to making false accusations of rape.
False accusation of rape - Wikipedia

I do think @Ter ‘s recommendation has merit.

[Pants-of-dog]

To get back to the subject of this thread, would our resident feminists agree that the false accuser should get the same sentence the accused would have received now that she was caught lying ?

This would imply that we should give different sentences to people despite the fact that they commit the same crime: making false allegations.

Why should false allegations by women be punished more than others?

[Red_Army]

Because it hurts feelings.

[Ter]

This would imply that we should give different sentences to people despite the fact that they commit the same crime: making false allegations.

The judicial system already hands out different sentences for identical crimes. Like for murder for instance. It depends on the circumstances, was it premeditated ? Was it out of greed or jealousy, was it accidental?

The allegations in this case were quite serious, with accusation of causing grievous bodily harm and so on.

The innocent guy would have had his life totally destroyed.

Because it hurts feelings.

RA persists with his useless trolling.
At least he is not bringing up age in this case, like he often does (coffin dodger, granpa...)
What happened to you RA?

[Red_Army]

The judicial system already hands out different sentences for identical crimes. Like for murder for instance. It depends on the circumstances, was it premeditated ? Was it out of greed or jealousy, was it accidental?

The allegations in this case were quite serious, with accusation of causing grievous bodily harm and so on.

The innocent guy would have had his life totally destroyed.


RA persists with his useless trolling.
At least he is not bringing up age in this case, like he often does (coffin dodger, granpa...)
What happened to you RA?

False accusations of murder destroy lives, but you dont care about that because it doesn't have to do with feminism.

[Ter]

False accusations of murder destroy lives, but you dont care about that because it doesn't have to do with feminism.

You are jumping to conclusions. Of course I care about false accusations of murder, I care about all false accusations. This thread is very specifically about a false accusation about assault by an ex. Stay on topic and answer my very precise question please. Should this accuser get the same sentence as the accused if he were guilty ?

[Eauz]

Feminist are hurting their cause and male allies by performing these acts of distrust.

[SolarCross]

Doesn't perjury cover the crime of false witness already?

[Pants-of-dog]

The judicial system already hands out different sentences for identical crimes. Like for murder for instance. It depends on the circumstances, was it premeditated ? Was it out of greed or jealousy, was it accidental?

The allegations in this case were quite serious, with accusation of causing grievous bodily harm and so on.

The innocent guy would have had his life totally destroyed.

The different factors affecting sentencing in murder make sense.

How does your idea make sense?

With this logic, the false claimant would end up serving sentences for crimes they did not commit instead of the one they did.

Tell me, do you think this person should receive a sentence that is more severe than the sentence given to a man who drugs, sexually assaults, and kills a woman?

You are jumping to conclusions. Of course I care about false accusations of murder, I care about all false accusations. This thread is very specifically about a false accusation about assault by an ex.

I find this difficult to believe since the only false allegations ever discussed on these forum are false sexual assault allegations, or attacks like this one.

Stay on topic and answer my very precise question please. Should this accuser get the same sentence as the accused if he were guilty ?

No, because that would mean that different people would get different sentences for committing the same crimes.

————————————

Feminist are hurting their cause and male allies by performing these acts of distrust.

I guess you know she was a feminist because you are one of these male allies and know her personally.

[Ter]

How does your idea make sense?

I find it sensible that this person who tried to destroy the other person's life, out of malice no less, should have her life destroyed also. I know that sounds biblical but it should also serve as an exampe to others.

Tell me, do you think this person should receive a sentence that is more severe than the sentence given to a man who drugs, sexually assaults, and kills a woman?

I cannot answer your question because you refuse to answer my question.
I'll show you mine but you show yours first.

I find this difficult to believe since the only false allegations ever discussed on these forum are false sexual assault allegations, or attacks like this one.

Take note that I am not the OP of this thread. If someone opens a thread about false accusation for murder, I will contribute to it.

No, because that would mean that different people would get different sentences for committing the same crimes.

We have already established that this makes sense. The judge should have enough leeway to determine appropriate sentencing.

[Pants-of-dog]

I find it sensible that this person who tried to destroy the other person's life, out of malice no less, should have her life destroyed also. I know that sounds biblical but it should also serve as an exampe to others.

To me, this sounds like vengeance, not justice.

I cannot answer your question because you refuse to answer my question.
I'll show you mine but you show yours first.

What did you ask? If you asked if I agree with your idea, then the answer is obviously no.

You asked Red_Army a qeustion, but not me. Thatis the only question you seem to have asked that was not rhetorical. Now, please answer mine.

Take note that I am not the OP of this thread. If someone opens a thread about false accusation for murder, I will contribute to it.

I have already explained why I doubt this.

We have already established that this makes sense. The judge should have enough leeway to determine appropriate sentencing.

You are discussing judicial leeway.

I am discussing differences in sentencing like executing one person and giving the next guy a 50$ fine.

[Ter]

To me, this sounds like vengeance, not justice.

Justice and vengeance overlap to a great extent.

Now, please answer mine.

I think that person should be sentenced in a way that is appropriate to the crime she committed.
The judge, within her considerable leeway, will decide exactly how long se should be incarcerated.
Try not to mix this criminal deed with other deeds. Each as to be looked at, with the circumstances taken into account.

I have already explained why I doubt this.

You are fee to doubt my good intentions.
By the way, I fail to see what this case has to do with feminism.

You are discussing judicial leeway.

I am discussing differences in sentencing like executing one person and giving the next guy a 50$ fine.

And yet, this is what happens in reality.
Some people kill other people and get the death penalty or life behind bars whilst others get away with it. I think the judge is in the best position to come to a fair sentencing.