Chris Harman - Politics | PoFo

Wandering the information superhighway, he came upon the last refuge of civilization, PoFo, the only forum on the internet ...

Discourse exclusively on the basis of historical materialist methodology.
Forum rules: No one line posts please. This forum is for discussion based on Marxism, Marxism-Leninism and similar revisions. Critique of topics not based on historical materialism belongs in the general Communism forum.
User avatar
By Ombrageux
A very lucid thinker on world history (particularly socialist episodes) and the intricacies of Marxist theorists. articles.

Socialist worker obit.

Guardian obit.

The Guardian wrote:Chris Harman obituary

Writer, editor and leading light of the Socialist Workers party

In 2005 Chris Harman was writing about how the 30-year project to publish the collected works of Marx and Engels was done. It is 50 volumes long and he was reviewing Vol 50, having read the previous 49 one by one as they had appeared. Of course, he had read them all. Harman, who has died aged 66 in Cairo, Egypt, following a cardiac arrest, was the kind of Marxist who is never satisfied with second-hand summaries. To get a handle on why he was like this, we have to go back to the 1950s when Marxism was largely in the hands of communists and, as Orwell's Animal Farm shows, the link between Marx's ideas and the communist tyrannies was nothing more than a distorted rhetoric.

Harman went to Watford grammar school, with its staff ranging from officer class traditionalists to old Welsh socialists and young CND-ers, the place run by the maverick, leftward-moving Harry Rée. I think I had my first glimpse of him there, as the friend of one of the school's senior lefties. He headed off to Leeds University in 1961 and became engrossed in a new Marxism, which tried to encapsulate several major bodies of thought, history and action: Marx's critique of capitalism, the Bolshevik and German revolutions of the early 20th century, a Marxist analysis of the Soviet bloc, and a turn to the revolutionary potential of the different kinds of working class across the world. This was a project that had begun in the 1930s, and Chris made his way to one of the several tiny organisations that had been trying to sustain and develop these ideas: the Socialist Review Group, whose main theorist was Tony Cliff.

In 1964, he moved on to the London School of Economics (LSE) to do a PhD with the present foreign secretary's father, Ralph Miliband. At the time, revolution was coming from the American civil rights movement, and anti-colonial, anti-apartheid and anti-Vietnam war campaigns. Little did we know that the LSE canteen and the Holborn pubs had turned into a Left Bank of debate. The LSE became a focal point for the sit-ins and free universities in this country.

I remember hearing Chris speak there, one moment alongside Danny Cohn-Bendit, the next with a shop steward from the occupation of the Renault factory in France, another at a demonstration against the Vietnam war. The Socialist Review Group had become the International Socialists (IS). "Neither Washington nor Moscow," they proclaimed, and many socialists, orthodox Trotskyists and communists recoiled from the hostility Harman directed at the Soviet Union. At one meeting, I recall how it seemed incredible to some that he could support Vietnam's fight against the US but be critical of Ho Chi Minh's Communist party. The events in Paris and the rest of France, he would claim, proved the point: existing parties claiming to be Marxist were unwilling and unable to make a revolution.

Everything Chris did over the next 40 years was geared towards creating a political party that was able and willing. With IS and its successor, the Socialist Workers party, he spent his life speaking, writing, editing, organising and campaigning. He was editor of the International Socialism Journal from 2004 and had previously edited Socialist Worker for more than two decades. In conversation his eyes would move between the middle distance and the floor, his ears picking up on every word, his replies indicating that he was relating what you were saying to the library in his head.

He didn't finish the PhD but produced a constant stream of articles, editorials and books: the book that would become Class Struggles in Eastern Europe (originally published in 1974 as Bureaucracy and Revolution in Eastern Europe), which developed the theory that the Soviet bloc was "state capitalist"; a history of the German revolution in The Lost Revolution: Germany 1918 to 1923 (1983); and the Marxist classic A People's History of the World (1999). At various times, his articles, which mostly homed in on the economics of the moment, coagulated into books: Explaining the Crisis appeared in 1984, and this year he produced Zombie Capitalism.

His style of speaking was rapid but analytic, good on irony and contradiction; his lifestyle frugal in the extreme. He was untempted by academe or celebrity. It was always a regret and an irritation to me why newspaper and TV debates about wars or the state of global capitalism did not call on him. That was a loss – and to hear that it is a permanent loss is deeply sad. Yet he leaves behind a terrific body of work that challenges received opinion.

He is survived by his partner Talat and children Seth and Sinead.

• Chris Harman, socialist and journalist, born 8 November 1942; died 7 November 2009
User avatar
By Dave
Another traitor dead. I'd celebrate, but it seems like his life's work was relatively insignificant.
User avatar
By HoniSoit
Ah I still have his A People's History of the World that I haven't read.

User avatar
By Parvus
A great loss for the international socialist movement. He will be missed.

One of the books I have read after getting interested in Marxism was his book called "How Marxism Works". Very clean, simple explanations that could make my grandmother grasp the idea of dialectics and historical materialism. I also have his pamphlet about the party and the class, which is also a magnificient work.

I'm looking forward to reading his "A People's History of the World" as well as "Eastern Europe: The Storm Breaks" and his last work "Zombie Capitalism".

He was also a great speaker. I listened to him here in Turkey on imperialism, capitalism's crisis and 1968. They all were wonderful speeches.

For a blog that contains some of his writings, check this website.

For his last speech in Cairo, see this video:

So long, comrade! It was a great chance and honor to have you.

Now we shall remember Tony Cliff's words one more time: "Do not mourn, organise!"
User avatar
By Goldberk
An interesting writer and political thinker, a great shame that his efforts were within the SWP.
By a777pilot
Dave wrote:Another traitor dead. I'd celebrate, but it seems like his life's work was relatively insignificant.

Well said. Well said.
User avatar
By HoniSoit
it seems like his life's work was relatively insignificant.

Well said. Well said.

I would agree to an extent. Chris Harman, like goldberk mentioned, devoted most of his energy within the SWP and the Marxist movement, and is thus little known outside of these circles and not really a significant public figure on the Left. It is also partly because there is a quite strong dogmatic element in his writings which is unlikely to attract people who are not already convinced of the correctness of Marxism.
Trump, Oh my god !

Except when they work to achieve a goal, like P[…]

1. "capitalism" is not the problem. […]

1) I am not sure what to think of any of this. […]

Jacinda vs ScoMo[…]