- 14 Jan 2014 17:02
#14352865
Did I state that it was?
Did I state that it was?
See above.
Did I state that it was?
Communism, as advanced by Marx and Engels, was never used to describe a system that currently, or ever, existed. This is not true for "capitalism."
You are deliberately attempting to redefine words and twist reality to try and make this not so.
There has always been a state in any society that has called itself capitalist, or been regarded as capitalist. I am a history expert. I wrote a piece about how I feel about whether it's, "inherently statist," that you are attempting to thought-police away by twisting reality and redefining words.
Alis Volat Propriis; Tiocfaidh ár lá; Proletarier Aller Länder, Vereinigt Euch!
mum wrote:But it is not inherently statist.
Did I state that it was?
mum wrote:But it is not inherently statist.
Did I state that it was?
mum wrote:No, they do not.
See above.
mum wrote:Perhaps, but again that doesn't mean it is inherently statist.
Did I state that it was?
mum wrote:Don't be silly, I think you are talking about communism. The lack of "masters" is actually a defining feature of the an-cap libertarians. Come on now, I'm pretty sure you have figured that out by now.
Communism, as advanced by Marx and Engels, was never used to describe a system that currently, or ever, existed. This is not true for "capitalism."
mum wrote:I think you are talking about communism again, please try and stay on topic.
You are deliberately attempting to redefine words and twist reality to try and make this not so.
mum wrote:Maybe, maybe not. I'm not a history expert. But either way, that doesn't mean it is inherently statist
There has always been a state in any society that has called itself capitalist, or been regarded as capitalist. I am a history expert. I wrote a piece about how I feel about whether it's, "inherently statist," that you are attempting to thought-police away by twisting reality and redefining words.
Alis Volat Propriis; Tiocfaidh ár lá; Proletarier Aller Länder, Vereinigt Euch!