The Remorse Fallacy - Politics Forum.org | PoFo

Wandering the information superhighway, he came upon the last refuge of civilization, PoFo, the only forum on the internet ...

Crime and prevention thereof. Loopholes, grey areas and the letter of the law.
Forum rules: No one line posts please.
User avatar
By Robert Urbanek
#15058683
A criminal’s display of remorse if often used by a judge in determining length of sentence or by a parole board in deciding if a felon will be released from prison. But are demonstrations of remorse a valid consideration for anything?

Does a display of remorse simply give an advantage to the sly, manipulative offender who can say what the judge wants to hear and a disadvantage to the stupid pigheaded criminal who can’t talk his way out of anything? Even a seemingly genuine display of remorse can be suspect. We know, for example, that many wife beaters will tell their spouse how sorry they are and promise never to repeat what they did, but then they continue the abuse.

As for considering parole, the best and most objective standards would seem to be good behavior in prison, “aging out” of reckless youthful behavior, useful vocational training, and social contacts and job prospects outside the prison.

“I am not aware of any studies that show that insight and remorse are correlated to recidivism,” says Heidi Rummel, the director of the Post-Conviction Justice Project at the University of Southern California Gould School of Law. (Source: “How to Get Out of Prison,” The New York Times Magazine, Jan. 5, 2020.)
User avatar
By Donna
#15058700
Remorse should be taken into account at a judge's discretion if it is uncovered by court-approved evaluation. That would be more scientific than simply assessing behavior during incarceration, which is typically influenced by a coercive inmate subculture that doesn't reveal anything about a convict's rehabilitative prospects.
User avatar
By Godstud
#15058753
Remorse is a sign that the person is not irredeemable, or a psychopath/sociopath, and thus incurable.
Impeachment in Wonderland

@blackjack21 Your responses do not address my […]

Dog lovers damage the planet

Kudos to you for rescuing a stray, Qatz. Our own […]

Trump has been impeached

Its a beautiful history. Natives killed natives. […]

New Guy!

Hi, I'm Indy, derived from the fact that I am fie[…]