Why Communism is predicted to Fail? (Example) - Page 2 - Politics Forum.org | PoFo

Wandering the information superhighway, he came upon the last refuge of civilization, PoFo, the only forum on the internet ...

Workers of the world, unite! Then argue about Trotsky and Stalin for all eternity...
Forum rules: No one line posts please.
#14529210
Decky wrote:It is a massive straw man. Communists don't believe everyone should get the same wage so your whole opening post is garbage. Do you think the Soviet Union put the first man in space by paying its rocket scientists the same as its milkmen?

0/10 read some books.


I have read couple books from Lenin, Trotsky and Marx not many as I would like but I'm going to work on that...
#14529214
fuser wrote:Read this, philiphos. Its short concise and in faq format by Engels. I couldn't think of any better starting point than this.


Thanka for sharing, I guess I'm going to finish reading value price and profit and start reading 1844 manuscrits
#14529217
fuser wrote:good choices.

Looking forward to the day when you dispose your Kennedy avatar in favor of Lenin.


If that day come is yet far away, anyway I have one doubt following "from each according to his abilities to each according to his needs" let's say that I want to have a holiday home, not a need but a desire, how would that be? Would I be able to have it? How was that in the soviet union?
#14529220
The Clockwork Rat wrote:People got holidays in the USSR.


I know that LOL, I'm talking about a second home that i just use to spend my holidays or weekends would that be possible?
#14529222
philiphos wrote:I know that LOL, I'm talking about a second home that i just use to spend my holidays or weekends would that be possible?

Only if you are a party member and jewish.

Actually I think jews have increasingly given up on communism since Stalin betrayed them which is why they don't push the commie gospel any more. They still like central banks though, it doesn't give them total hegemony over the goyim but at least they get unlimited imaginary money with which to freeride off them.
#14529235
fuser wrote:Looking forward to the day when you dispose your Kennedy avatar in favour of Lenin.


I think that, as mythic figures, they can serve complimentary purposes. Kennedy shows up the inadequacies of reformism; a man who was undermined and opposed by the establishment at every turn. He serves to illustrate the nature of the capitalist state; that it is not controlled by politicians but by economic actors.

If you want to go a step further, you can say that he illustrates exactly what happens to men who don't play ball within the narrow confines of the liberal-capitalist system. Some might be averse to "conspiracy theories", however.

...

Lenin, however, shows what men can achieve when they break the rules; the ideal revolutionary figure, with a commitment to the unceasing advance of socialism.

So, I don't think they contradict one another.
#14529240
philiphos wrote:I'm talking about a second home that i just use to spend my holidays or weekends would that be possible?

That would depend on the circumstances of the time and place you live. There are already countries (Denmark?) where you have to get planning permission to convert a residence into a second home. There is no ideological opposition to the concept within Communism, afaik.
#14529249
The Clockwork Rat wrote:An AnCap turned monarchist is about the last person to take advice from when it comes to being politically relevant.

Nevermind your prejudices against the source of the advice, consider the advice on its own merits. That is wisest. Is not state backed usury the big problem of our times?
#14529258
The Clockwork Rat wrote:Ha. We have many problems of which that is only one.

Well sure but the only one marxists fixate on isn't even a problem. If you are narrowly concerned with economic relations then usury surely is the most pernicious problem. What is worse?

Liberia is not indistinguishable from other Afric[…]

Taiwan-China crisis.

I don't put all the blame on Taiwan. I've said 10[…]

“Whenever the government provides opportunities a[…]

Russia-Ukraine War 2022

Afghanistan defeated the USSR, we are not talking[…]